This behaviour is desired almost universally
"Almost" is the key word is our situation I guess.
I did not say the plugin didn't work - I said it did not work consistently for us. While I would not change the rating based on this conversation, I would be open to deleting the review altogether. I do not see a way to do so. If that is possible please let me know how.
We may give WP RSS Aggregator another chance in the future. We simply can't waste any more time with it at this point when 2 of the free plugins are doing exactly what we need them to do.
Thank you for the explanations and support.